Steam
Symbiogenesis
66
Final Score
Web3 Interactive Narrative
Release Date: 2023
Developer: Square Enix
Publisher: Square Enix

Symbiogenesis

An experimental Web3 work developed by Square Enix, positioned as an 'NFT collection art experience'. Centered on cooperative story mode, requires all players to advance the plot together, with Discord community playing an important role.

Art Appreciation

Symbiogenesis is a work with a very limited audience in a small circle, and the special thing is that this small circle refers to the crypto community - it's a so-called Web3 game. But it's also genuinely produced by Square Enix, and you can see a strong SE flavor from the logo's art style. Why do game players have such hostility towards Web3 games? Various Web3 games on the market eventually become money-grabbing games. Crypto people invented the new term GameFi, focusing on the Financial aspect. No matter how it changes, it's all about crypto people wanting to make money, so game players naturally don't want to be harvested. But Web3 games, conceptually speaking, still have merit, it's just that there hasn't been any breakout, phenomenally successful masterpiece so far. Symbiogenesis gives me a glimmer of hope. It's naturally good that major companies are willing to layout in this track. I must clarify that Symbiogenesis is definitely not stunning, probably just the same staff as SE's pile of gacha mobile games, but overall it's commendable and contains possibilities in its gameplay. This work features multiple NFT collectible art characters as protagonists, adventuring on the "Floating Continent." To solve the mysteries of the floating continent, there are three types of stories: "Main Story," "Side Story," and "Collaborative Story." Since players cannot see the full story from the beginning, timely cooperation with others is also the main gameplay of Symbiogenesis. The official encourages players to discuss and communicate on Discord, so the Discord community plays a very important role, which I think is the most uniquely innovative aspect. The entire game's progress requires all players to work together to advance and unlock the entire "Floating Continent" story. This is not a simple RPG where you go through the plot, fight monsters, get equipment and trade, but rather hands the story progression to all players, making everyone a pioneer, which is challenging. This is what I consider a good evaluation - the return of gameplay and the disappearance of speculation. As of today, the game story is still stuck in Chapter 1, and the current game content is not that much, but as mentioned before, this work will have a total of six chapters, worth looking forward to updated content. In a word: We want Web3's creativity, not GameFi's money-grubbing. Web3 games don't need to sweep the entire player community, but that doesn't prevent them from achieving great things and opening up new worlds with endless imagination.

Rating Breakdown

Core Gameplay & Fun
40%

Deductions

Gameplay Depth
-3 pts

There isn't much content yet; the story is still stuck at Chapter 1, so depth is limited.

Learning Curve
-5 pts

As a Web3 game, the barrier is high for ordinary players, who need to understand NFTs, cryptocurrency and so on. And since each chapter is driven by players, newcomers find it very hard to get into and are left completely lost.

Player Agency
-3 pts

Same as above: new players will just be lost in the game's complex mechanics, with no sense of immersion at all.

Highlights

Core Mechanics

It hands story progression to all players, making everyone a trailblazer, which is challenging. This is a return to gameplay and the end of speculation.

Innovation

The Discord community plays a major role, which is its most innovative aspect. Cooperative story mode requires all players to work together to push it forward, which is quite innovative.

Immersion

Cooperating with others at the right moments is the core gameplay, and community collaboration brings a unique sense of immersion.

Technical Performance & Stability
25%

Deductions

Hardware Compatibility
-1 pts

As a Web3 game, it requires connecting a crypto wallet and the like, so the technical barrier is relatively high.

Highlights

Program Stability

As a Web3 game from SE, its technical performance is fairly stable, with no obvious technical problems.

Visuals & Audio
15%

Deductions

Art Style & Consistency
-2 pts

The character art isn't bad, but like the existing NFT market it's made into a cookie-cutter set of artwork, which feels very contrived.

Highlights

Art Style & Consistency

You can sense a strong SE flavor just from the logo's art style; it keeps Square Enix's artistic signature.

Story & Narrative
10%

Deductions

Narrative Coherence
-2 pts

Since players can't see the whole story at the start, narrative coherence suffers somewhat.

Highlights

Main Story Design

There are three kinds of stories you need to know — main story, side stories and cooperative stories — giving the design rich layers.

Presentation Quality

Cooperative stories only unlock through the combined effort of all players; this narrative model is highly innovative.

World Building Depth

The floating continent setting is interesting, and the whole story will run to two million characters, with a fully built world.

Content & Longevity
10%

Deductions

Content Richness
-3 pts

As of today, the story is still stuck at Chapter 1, and there isn't much content yet.

Microtransaction System
-2 pts

An NFT-based collectible art experience; it avoids pure GameFi money-grubbing but still involves cryptocurrency trading.

Monetization Balance
-5 pts

The nature of the game means there's no spending balance: to get better NFTs or "airdrops", the Web3 world quantifies these contributions, so players have to invest more. There's no such thing as freeloading, let alone the spending balance of traditional games.

Player Feedback Response
-5 pts

A niche work with a very limited audience; ordinary gamers are very hostile to Web3 games, so market acceptance is low.

Community Atmosphere
-3 pts

Since the players who stick with it are all crypto people, the actual community reeks of money, with everything revolving around profit, far removed from what games are about.

Highlights

Update Content Quality

There will be six chapters in total, so the updates are worth looking forward to. It's a good thing that a major company like SE is willing to stake out this space.

Community Features

The Discord community plays a very important role; the developers encourage players to discuss and exchange ideas, making community interaction strong.