
Phantom Blade Zero
S-GAME's wuxia action RPG wears a Soulslike shell but is noticeably more approachable, playing more like a pure action game. Soul-forging-driven exploration, the original songs and the shadow-puppet sequence stand out; derivative Soulslike tropes, technical issues and unskippable cutscenes hold it back.
Art Appreciation
Rating Breakdown
Deductions
Very derivative Soulslike premises: a strange plague, an abandoned mountain village, an eerie cult and its followers. The seemingly vast conspiracy in the background really just has several chapters of maps revolving around one regional town. And as noted above, the lowered difficulty makes this feel more like an action game than a Soulslike, so there was no need at all for something as obviously Souls-like as the bells.
A young game studio; the sense of impact lacks a bit of refinement.
Highlights
The difficulty is considerably lower than other Soulslikes: enemies don't respawn, and bosses can be fought in stages.
Deductions
A hidden map suddenly starts dropping frames. Some cutscenes and boss fights freeze for no reason.
After a graphics driver update, the game actually has to recompile its shaders, and it takes a long time… Not sure whose fault it is, but it's the first time I've run into this.
A Soulslike that adds jumping, and you get stuck in a rock right at the start… Many terrain barriers are passed with special buttons, jumping included, so the point of jumping is unclear. You can stand in midair over an open well, and the text made me think I could jump.
Deductions
It brings in many familiar traditional elements such as Buddha statues, but they're clearly less striking than in games that capture World Heritage sites on location. The shadow-puppet sequence, though, is beautifully made and tells its story well.
Clipping is fairly widespread.
The quest progress UI overlaps with item bar effects.
Cutscenes can't be skipped, and some aren't that important; for example, if you accidentally trigger the shadow-puppet show in the theater a second time, you have to sit through it again…
The actors are largely poker-faced; the overall performance experience isn't top-tier.
Highlights
The original songs are a plus, and the lyrics are carefully crafted around the story's themes.
Deductions
Side quests are well proportioned overall, neither too many nor too few, and tempt you to clear them all. Points off because some are too hasty: in the Lan family young master's big-twist quest to rescue the children, I expected to actually escort them to the docks, but it's just a cutscene.
Highlights
Although there's a setup of overt and hidden martial worlds, the story as a whole isn't very complex, filling in the plot gradually through flashbacks. Even so, the game does tell a complete story.
Highlights
There aren't any extra collectibles, but if you count weapons and soul-forging materials, they're fun in themselves and keep pulling you to explore beyond the main story.